.
Feedback

Hey, Mom and Dad: How Much Homework Is Too Much For Grade-School Kids?

Parents, Patch wants to hear from you on the questions that get families talking. This week we're wondering: How much homework is appropriate to be sending home with grade-school students?

Welcome to "Hey, Mom and Dad"—a weekly feature in which we ask our Facebook fans to share their views on parenting. We're starting off with a question we posed last week on the Patch Facebook pages.

Fall is here and your child is no doubt getting to know their new teacher and adjusting to the demands of a new school year. But with most students also juggling a myriad of extracurricular activities, school isn't the only thing on their plate.

How much homework is too much for a grade-school student?

Take a look at what people had to say and join the conversation in the comments section.

Jen Baxley Sunleaf: I would say no more than 30 to 45 minutes. My boys don't get home until 3:50, they do homework, some days baseball practice and every kid needs some playtime and then if course dinner and family time! Homework is important, but so is family and individual time. Too much homework after being in school for 6 hours can burn the kids out and not do as we'll as they should. — Batavia Patch Facebook

Tammy Churchill Pesenti: My son is in 3rd grade does 1-2 hrs per night depending, but he has advanced math and I do require the 30 minute per night of reading as 'suggested' by the teacher and additional work on the online resources suggested to compliment the work that is sent home. It helps reinforce what they are learning so he feels like he has the skill mastered and is ready to move forward to the next level. — Elmhurst Patch Facebook

Laurie Brennan: We have had an hour or more on most days since second grade. Between math flashcards, practice math tests, practice spelling (all things I have to help with), plus reading and any daily homework from the teacher, we are happy to be done in under an hour!! We have a good healthy snack after school, then get to work. It isn't too bad though. As long as I have a good attitude about it, the kids seem to as well. — Geneva Patch Facebook

Jessica Moran Rench: I believe kids homework should be to go home and PLAY. Then read a bit before bed. Homework is for the birds. — Glen Ellyn Patch Facebook

Michelle Thompson: They have school all day. They should not have homework. Kids need downtime. Kids have activities after school and because they have so much homework they r not getting enough sleep. Kids need balance. Hours of school is enough for one day!!! — Lisle Patch Facebook

Melissa Carson Zdenovec: School comes first, before sports, but more than an hour at that age is too much. — Naperville Patch Facebook

Krista Oleksiak Lipnisky: I give my 4th graders about 45 min a night...and then they must read each night for 30 min. :) — St. Charles Patch Facebook

Austin Norton: I'm homeschooled. All my work is homework! — Wheaton Patch Facebook

So what's your take? Tell us in the comments. 

Rick Nagel (Editor) September 25, 2012 at 01:29 pm
One Facebook commenter said the rule of thumb is 10 minutes per grade level—at least for the grade-school years. It really shouldn't be more than an hour, but I can understand why it's hard to orchestrate at the middle school and high school level, when each student has multiple teachers.
Lisa Kennedy September 26, 2012 at 02:43 am
I don't think there is enough time for kids to be kids. We didn't have hours of homework when I was a kid. If the teachers are actually teaching (and they should be since we pay a fortune in taxes) then homework should be minimal (30 minutes total per day if that ) unless there is a small project or they have to study for a test. And truthfully if your kids are paying attention in school then it shouldn't take too long to review for a test.
Bailey leonard April 11, 2013 at 06:03 pm
I'm in 6th grade and I like never get homework
JanS April 11, 2013 at 06:22 pm
Homework is necessary to teach self discipline and because not all students work at the same pace. Memorizing math facts and spelling words, and doing projects will always require homework. However, especially at the elementary level, homework should be kept to a minimum. Children learn through play and family activities. Parents are responsible for the raising of the whole child. Teachers are responsible for their academic education. Parents and teachers must work together in order to provide the best for all children.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Lisle Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Dianne Arp June 19, 2013 at 12:24 am
there. We checked with OSHA, there is no such violation. Lies, lies, lies. If they let you in theRead More back room you'd see the horrific, cruel conditions in which those dogs/puppies are housed. The puppies and dogs inside Puppy (Mill) Parlor are NOT rescued dogs. They do NOT hold "Adoption Events." They are NOT a rescue. They are NOT a 501c3 organization. If they were, Tammy Coglianese would have a Tax ID number issued by the IRS. She doesn't have one! They sell sick and dying puppy mill puppies to unsuspecting customers who believe they're being told the truth. They'll tell you anything you want to hear, lie right to your face, in order to get their hands on your credit card. And being "licensed by the Dept of Ag" means absolutely nothing. Puppy mills are also licensed by the DOA. And as if that's not enough, Puppy (Mill) Parlor was listed on the Horrible 100 Puppy Mills in the United States. They're the ONLY pet store in the entire U.S. listed in the report! Google it and see for yourself. Go to a shelter, or a rescue. There are even breed-specific rescues out there. If you're looking for a Schnauzer, Google: "Schnauzer rescue Illinois" and lists of Schnauzer-only rescues will pop up. If you buy a sick and dying puppy from Puppy (Mill) Parlor, you'll spend thousands in vet bills and most likely the dog will die anyway. We've heard from many, many people who've had exactly that happen. If you've purchased a dog from this hell hole, go to the Companion Animal Protection Society (CAPS) website at caps-web.org and complete a pet purchase complaint form.
Rita June 19, 2013 at 08:49 am
You can be JUST within the DOA's guidelines and still found acceptable, doesn't mean it ISRead More acceptable. Selling dogs in a store to the DOA has the same guidelines as raising and selling of cattle. Why were you thrown out of the AKC, or did you forget to mention that the biggest dog canine association in the COUNTRY even disowned and distanced themselves for you? Why won't you show people what's in the back room if you have nothing to hide? Leave the door open 24/7 if you have nothing to hide. You stated in your so called "interview" it was against OSHA rules and regulations, once again a lie. If you only breed yorkies "now and then", where do the other dogs come from? I have no doubt you love dogs, why not they make you money. If you really loved dogs, you would treat them a heck of a lot better than you do. Where do the dogs in the back room get exercise? They are never walked or given exercise! How cruel! Why did the hair salon next door leave and why is there records of the two of you fighting over the stench that drove her business away? Why do you and your "workers" have to swear at the protesters, worse yet, in front of children? Why do you flip off kids that are out there? Why does the store front have to look like a junk store constantly? Where did you dumpster dive that "adoption" sign you had? Oh that's right, Petco, never mind. Wonder if they knew you were using their trademarked sign? Why aren't the dogs records directly next to the dogs that being sold? As for the "rescue" dogs, when they come from your back store pit, the only reason those would be rescues is because they are finally getting released from that place! You're telling people you're working with rescues, WHAT rescues? NAME them! Oh that's right, you can't. Just more lies! How do you sleep at night Tammy while all those dogs lie in those cages crying at night, peeing and pooping on each other? Sick, just sick! But as they say, every dog has their day.
Heather S. June 19, 2013 at 12:03 pm
"All puppies I sell or rescue dogs that I arrange adoptions for are up to date on all necessaryRead More vaccinations for their age including Rabies shot. The puppies have a health guarantee until their first birthday for any genetic abnormalities." What tests are being done to ensure the genetic health of your dogs? A vet check is not a health guarantee. Most genetic conditions don't start to show until a dog is at least 2 years old. Actual genetic testing can sometimes be expensive. Are your dogs getting knee, hip, eye, etc tests by a certified organization such as OFA, and you can show proof of it?
Back room of the Puppy Parlor
Rita June 19, 2013 at 08:48 am
It's sad to think someone that seems fairly intelligent would really think two hours of peopleRead More legally protesting ONE store, once a week, is going to take down an entire community's downtown business. No one can be that blind.
Rita June 19, 2013 at 10:31 am
I'm going to be truly honest here, I could care less whether you believe in what we're doing.Read More Everyone has their opinion, as I'm sure you are well aware of the old saying about opinions.... My real problem here isn't whether you believe this woman is telling the truth or whether we are, doesn't matter to me. However, to say we are ruining Lisle's downtown protesting a store once a week for two hours is ludicrous. Lisle's downtown has been in a tail spin for years now. They tried rejuvenating the downtown with it's makeover, unfortunately during that period of time, it drove many businesses out of downtown because people weren't coming because of the construction and mass confusion that was downtown. Millions spent, looks beautiful, but now there's no businesses. Meanwhile, businesses are turned away because it doesn't fit into the "vision" the current board has for Lisle. It's been years with this "vision". Apparently it's not working, time to get a new vision. You need a business that is going to pull businesses into the area, such as Cadence Health Care that wanted to lease/buy the old Bank of America building, but were turned away because they aren't a retail business. Retail business or not, that would've brought a LOT of business into Lisle. Instead they, or people like yourself, keep and support a business like Puppy Parlor and blame protesters for the lack of business downtown. How long have you lived in and followed what actually goes on with the businesses in Lisle Roseanne? If you've followed it at all, you would've found out by now, we, the protesters, aren't the people shooting the businesses or Lisle in the foot.
Heather S. June 19, 2013 at 12:25 pm
Roseanne, "and what you are doing has not saved one dog." Really? You really think that?Read More People who are aware of this situation, are being directed to shelters or a supportive rescue like The Dog Patch in Naperville (which originally ran like a pet store, getting their puppies from commercial breeders, but have since turned over a new leaf, getting all their dogs from rescues.) SO MANY dogs have been saved from EDUCATING the public.
Lisle WatchDog June 12, 2013 at 05:57 pm
Tornado sirens in Joliet...22 miles from Lisle...
Lisle WatchDog June 12, 2013 at 07:05 pm
All Metra BNSF trains westbound delayed.
Lisle WatchDog June 12, 2013 at 08:36 pm
Funnel cloud pics Naperville...posted at 8 pmRead More http://naperville.patch.com/groups/announcements/p/storm_1eb456ae
Darren McRoy (Editor) June 10, 2013 at 01:45 pm
Patch posts mugshots as part of reporting on police actions. We can never be paid to removeRead More mugshots, and thus are not an "extortion website." We can always update articles and report on future developments in the adjudication process.
Maureen June 10, 2013 at 11:49 pm
kindly directed at the editor~ Sorry Mr. Editor, you will get no Mia culpeas from me. I findRead More your practice of posting large head shots on this site appalling and yes it's definitely a form of cyber-bulling and possibly putting innocent people's identity at risk. Other neighboring suburbs post the local police reports without the need of a picture. Many local area Patch.com sites post the names , their offense and where he/she was apprehended. That is sufficient. But as I observed under the previous editor, not only did the Lisle Patch allow one to read the names, offenses and location as provided by the Lisle Police. The Patch website also included pictures, ages and addresses of those cited. Thats when the Patch crossed the line. I'm sure you're aware of internet catfishing. You know where one's picture can be lifted and reposted elsewhere without their knowledge or consent. While I am thankful that you do not ask for monies to remove headshots , how can you guarantee the citizens of Lisle will not become victims of these other parasite websites? Yes, these folks may have used poor judgement . But sometimes nice people do stupid things. Hopefully it's a one-time incident. As much as I believe in the First Amendment , I believe a responsible editor balances FOIA with a person right to privacy. Who wants their children , neighbors , minister or potential employer finding one's headshot on a website like this. Especially should the case be thrown out and/or the person is found innocent. If Springfield legislates this correctly I would hope that you could not post pictures and other identifying information unless the person is found guilty.
Lisle WatchDog June 12, 2013 at 03:12 pm
Yet, the State of Illinois proposed its own "Tollway Website of Shame"?! Those that votedRead More against the tollway website of shame cited that people could get named on the site even if someone else was running up fines with their car. And Illinois website would also be an "extortion-style" site where people have to pay to get their name removed from the website. http://www.dailyherald.com/article/20130604/news/706049727/
Speaking up for the dogs in the back room of Puppy Parlor
jd June 15, 2013 at 02:37 pm
Good for you guys! The Lisle Puppy mill is run by sick human beings, and there's a special placeRead More reserved in hell for them, on account of thier horrific abuse and neglect of animals. I will join you next Sat if you protest again!